"This is my simple religion. There is no need for temples; no need for complicated philosophy. Our own brain, our own heart is our temple; the philosophy is kindness." Dalai Lama

The Case against the Polio Virus

by Janine Roberts

FILED IN: Health and Food · Issue 1

Is the ‘poliovirus’ the cause of infantile paralysis/polio? Or is it an ancient and harmless companion of the human race?

All the evidence suggests the latter:

1 It had been around humans for thousands of years and in nature only reproduces in human throats or guts. Such viruses are normally totally harmless, since we have become adapted to them and they to us. It lived in the dirt ingested by human infants, and did not hurt them. Instead it helped activate their immune system, giving them a stronger resistance to illness.

2 If it were the dangerous pathogen that causes infantile paralysis, then it would be more common in countries with infantile paralysis epidemics, and less common in countries with no infantile paralysis epidemics. But the reverse is true.

3 To say it causes polio may violate one of the most famous laws of virology. These are called the Koch Postulates. They set up the rules for declaring a disease to be caused by a virus . The 1st Postulate states that the virus must be found in every case of the disease as defined by its symptoms – but the poliovirus was not always present in such cases of poliomyelitis.

4 It widely infects children without causing them any illness. The Koch Postulates lay down that if it causes a disease, it should do so whenever it infects.

5 It seemed mostly to infect the cleanest children of middle-class parents. Infectious viruses are not supposed to behave in this way: they are indiscriminate as to social class, and do not thrive in conditions of good hygiene. The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has published a theory to explain this extraordinary behaviour. The children of US middle-class parents were uniquely liable to fall ill with infantile paralysis because in their infancy parents kept them away from the dirt in which the virus lives.

This meant these children were not infected when it was safest – while protected by their mothers’ milk. Once again, the case against the polio virus….this theory contradicted everything known about infectious illness: good hygiene nearly always stops epidemics; with infantile paralysis, the CDC argued, good hygiene was the cause. Furthermore, the CDC’s theory was based on the assumption that working-class children are uniquely exposed to ordinary dirt. Yet surely middle-class children also go out into the garden? The theory was also conceived without checking medical reports on the early epidemics of infantile paralysis.

Referring to a 1908 epidemic in Massachusetts, US health inspector Herbert Emerson noted that most cases occurred in households with no sewers and low hygiene. If the CDC’s theory was sound these children would have had antibodies and been immune to polio. In reality, they were the ones who fell ill.

6 If guilty of causing paralysis, it would have to travel from the gut through the formidable blood-brain barrier that protects our brains and spinal cords. We still have not observed it doing this, despite many decades of intense research.

7 It is rarely found in human blood – the easiest route from the gut to the blood-brain barrier. Yet this is where Jonas Salk’s vaccine was supposed to intercept it.

8 It has never been observed reproducing in victims’ motor neurone cells.

An alternative proposition

Poliomyelitis researcher Dr Ralph Scobey suggested in 1954 a reason why viruses might be found on damaged motor neuron cells in cases of infantile paralysis. He posited that the body itself might activate or produce these viruses , perhaps when under threat or to clean up cellular damage.
While ‘the fundamental cause of human poliomyelitis appears to be a poison or toxin’, Scobey said, ‘the virus is synthesised or activated within the human body as a result of the poisoning’.
He suggested that the virus might remain ‘ dormant’ within cells until something activates it. We now know that the poliovirus can be dormant. It is also widely known that toxic-damaged tissues attract viruses. One of the standard tests for toxins, the Ames Assay, utilises the fact that if viruses mutate and multiply in the presence of a certain amount of a chemical then that amount is dangerously toxic.
Scobey went on to list anti-toxins that had proved effective in curing polio, citing 11 scientific papers written between 1936 and 1949.


  • Poisonous Vaccines The 1950’s race to be the first with a polio vaccine was led by Jonas Salk and Albert Sabin. Both designed polio vaccines intended to...
  • Superviruses and the epidemic of fear A daily scan through the newspapers and TV news gives the impression that the entire world is constantly invaded by new and horrible virus epidemics....
  • Is modern medicine founded on error? Modern medicine is firmly founded on the “Germ Theory of Disease,” promulgated by Louis Pasteur in the 1860s. Pasteur’s 140-year-old theory is still the medical...
  • What you haven’t been told about Aids In the CDC’s Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report of June 5th 1981, James Curran implied the existence of a major new sexually transmitted disease. This...
  • Living in a Toxic Soup As our bodies get poisonous and sick, so do our thoughts. It can’t be ignored any longer: the overload of toxic synthetic chemicals is slowly...
  • Pet vaccinations are a crime I believe that vets of the future, and our children’s doctors, will look back upon the vac­cination era with horror and shame. The horror will...


  1. I was born in 1942 so I remember what life was like before the polio vaccine. Parents were terrified. Every summer there were waves of polio cases. Kids died. Or worse, they were condemned to iron lungs “for life.”

    Swimming pools were closed. Picnics were cancelled. No one knew what caused it or how to avoid it.

    I lived less than half a mile from the famous Sister Kenny Hospital where the severest cases went. It was a busy place.

    Then the Salk and then Sabin vaccine arrived and in a matter of a few years, Sister Kenny’s hospital had no patients amd it closed.
    I just wish these anti-vaccination idiots could visit 1950 for a month. Or maybe they could drop in on hospitals in the 1920s when there were 100,000 to 200,000 cases of diphtheria every year in the United States, causing 13,000 to 15,000 deaths, most of them children.
    Or maybe they could witness a case of tetanus.

    I am infuriated by these smug ignoramuses who are clearly willing to let these horrible diseases stalk their own children, and by extension, everyone. What do they thibnk will happen if we all stop getting vaccinations?? We’ll be able to stave off yellow fever and tetanus with a homeopathic pill?

    A resurgence of these plagues will be on their heads! (Not that it will be any comfort to the rest of us.)

    Comment by Alex Swan

    “One of the biggest myths that antivaccinationists believe and like to use to stoke the fear of vaccines is the concept that they are full of “toxins.” The myth that mercury in the thimerosal preservative commonly used in vaccines in the U.S. until early 2002 was a major cause of autism is simply the most recent bogeyman used to try to argue that vaccines do more harm than good”

    Read the truth here: http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?p=9

    Comment by Polio Victim

  3. The media, the doctors, the hospitals, the drug companies, the “health” providers and most of the politicians all have a lot to lose when the majority of the population sees through the propaganda, particularly the vaccine propaganda. When I first started investigating vaccines I thought some were good and some were bad. What surprised me was not only the truth of the matter but how effectively the truth of the matter can be marginalized by the media. It is an almost effortless imperative dumped on a fairly gullible public. It’s not a conspiracy. It’s just the regular corrupt way that business has been conducted for decades.

    -Wily Elder Certified Behavior Analyst, Ocala, Florida, United States

    Comment by wilyelder

Leave a comment

Subscribe to comments on this post


Cover of Issue 28

Issue 29 of Biophile is going electronic and will be available soon. It will also be available to our international readers. Stay tuned or contact us for more details! find out more


I was just checking the website of the SEXPO which has just visited SA, this is what the Cape Town site says. . . . “The world’s largest Health, Sexuality and Lifestyle expo is coming back to Slaapstad and it’s bigger and sexier than ever! continue reading


Biophile magazine is published every two months by Biophile cc. The magazine is edited by Chris Lautenbach, while subscriptions and advertising are managed by Lindsay Mitchell.
The telephone number is 021 789 0694 and you can send faxes to 086 514 9668 and letters to PO Box 39277 Capricorn Square 7948.


Visit Ecotelly.com for more videos


Award Web

Biophile recently received recognition for its contribution to the print & internet category at the 20th SAB Environmentalist & Environmental Journalists of the year Awards. Congratulations to a dedicated team!