Steering away from ‘climate porn’
by Michael McCarthy
FILED IN: The Biofiles
Alarmist language used to discuss the threat of global warming is tantamount to “climate porn”, offering a thrilling spectacle but ultimately distancing the public from the problem, a leading progressive think tank has warned.
This alarmism, seen in almost every discussion about climate change, excludes the possibility of real action, suggesting the problem is too big to be overcome, according to a study published by Britain’s left-leaning Institute for Public Policy Research.
The institute examined more than 600 articles from the UK press, and more than 90 TV, radio and press advertisements, news clips and websites to find out how the media, government and green groups are communicating climate change.
It concluded that the discussion on climate change in Britain was confusing, contradictory, chaotic, and likely to make the public feel disempowered.
The report identified two ways of communicating the climate problem that should be avoided: using inflated or extreme language and focusing on small actions to solve the problem.
It warned that the “we’re all going to die” approach, which refers to climate change as “awesome, terrible, immense and beyond human control”, excludes the possibility of action.
“Alarmism might even become secretly thrilling – effectively a form of ‘climate porn’. It is seen in almost every form of discussion on the issue,” it said.
Green groups and the Government favour the “small actions” approach, characterised as “I’m doing my bit for the planet – and maybe my pocket”, which could be ineffective.
The report said: “It asks a large number of people to do a few small things to counter climate change. The language is one of ease and domesticity with references to kettles and cars, ovens and light switches. It is often placed alongside alarmism. It is likely to beg the question: how can this really make a difference?”
Instead of those approaches, the institute urged the Government and green groups to treat climate-friendly activity as a brand, “making it feel natural to the large numbers of people who are currently unengaged with the problem”.
Solutions to climate change could appeal to Britons’ sense of “ordinary heroism” as exemplified in the Battle of Britain. The argument on climate change should be treated as if it has already been won, the report said.
“If the public is to be persuaded of the need to act we must understand how climate change is being communicated in the UK,” said Simon Retallack, the institute’s head of climate change.
“Currently, climate communications too often terrify or thrill the reader or viewer while failing to make them feel that they can make a difference, which engenders inaction.
“Government and green groups should avoid giving the impression that ‘we are all doomed’ and spend less time convincing people that climate change is real.
“The focus should be on the big actions that people can take to address climate change, like switching to a hybrid car, fitting a wind turbine or installing cavity wall insulation, not just the small ones such as turning down the thermostat or switching off the lights.
“Climate-friendly behaviours need to be made to feel like ‘the kinds of things that people like us do’ to large groups of people.”
SIMILAR ARTICLES
- Is it time to just live with climate change? An article in this week’s Time magazine raises an interesting point about climate change. While there’s a growing consensus that global warming is real, the...
- Climate wars threaten billions A total of 46 nations and 2.7 billion people are now at high risk of being overwhelmed by armed conflict and war because of climate...
- Climate Change Alters Ocean Chemistry Stanford, CA— Researchers have discovered that the ocean’s chemical makeup is less stable and more greatly affected by climate change than previously believed. The researchers...
- Climate deal sealed by US U-turn Delegates at the UN summit in Bali have agreed a deal on curbing climate change after days of bitter wrangling. Agreement was reached after a U-turn...
- Biofuels are increasing poverty The replacement of traditional fuels with biofuels has dragged more than 30 million people worldwide into poverty, an aid agency report says. Oxfam says so-called...
- Biofuels could add to greenhouse gas emissions A new paper suggests that biofuel production may be contributing to an increase in greenhouse gas emissions.The lead author and Nobel laureate Paul Crutzen and...
CURRENT ISSUE
Issue 29 of Biophile is going electronic and will be available soon. It will also be available to our international readers. Stay tuned or contact us for more details! find out more
EDITORIAL
I was just checking the website of the SEXPO which has just visited SA, this is what the Cape Town site says. . . . “The world’s largest Health, Sexuality and Lifestyle expo is coming back to Slaapstad and it’s bigger and sexier than ever! continue reading
ABOUT BIOPHILE
Biophile magazine is published every two months by Biophile cc. The magazine is edited by Chris Lautenbach, while subscriptions and advertising are managed by Lindsay Mitchell.
The telephone number is 021 789 0694 and you can send faxes to 086 514 9668 and letters to PO Box 39277 Capricorn Square 7948.
ECOTELLY
Visit Ecotelly.com for more videos
AWARD
Biophile recently received recognition for its contribution to the print & internet category at the 20th SAB Environmentalist & Environmental Journalists of the year Awards. Congratulations to a dedicated team!
SPONSOR
RECENT COMMENTS